Opinion | A longtime conservative insider warns: The GOP can’t be saved (2022)

With the midterm elections hurtling into their final stretch, a group of Never Trumpers is pumping millions of dollars into ads aimed at defeating Republican candidates aligned with Donald Trump and his lies about the 2020 election.

Sign up for a weekly roundup of thought-provoking ideas and debatesArrowRight

At the core of this effort is a big question: Can Trump’s continued domination of the news cycle, and the intensifying revelations about his lawlessness, alienate a small but meaningful enough fraction of GOP-leaning voters to affect the outcome?

The Republican Accountability Project, which is chaired by Never Trumper and conservative movement veteran Bill Kristol, is betting that it’s possible. A PAC linked to the group is spending money to try to defeat more than a dozen of the Trumpiest GOP candidates, those who support the “big lie” such as Doug Mastriano and Kari Lake, who are running for governor in Pennsylvania and Arizona.

Advertisement

The group’s ads highlight ongoing revelations about Trump’s effort to overthrow our constitutional order, culminating in the violence of Jan. 6, 2021. And the stunning disclosures about Trump’s hoarding of state secrets have made his lawlessness even more central.

FollowGreg Sargent's opinionsFollow

I reached out to Kristol — who has been a fixture in the elite conservative and neoconservative establishments for decades — to discuss his group’s efforts, the future of the GOP, and the true nature of Never Trumpism. An edited and condensed version of our exchanges follows.

Greg Sargent: The fundamental premise of your efforts is that a percentage of Republican and GOP-leaning independent voters can in fact be peeled away from supporting GOP candidates, yes? How big is that percentage? Can they be induced to vote for Democratic candidates?

Advertisement

(Video) Religious Extremists Mix Trump Worship With Christian Nationalism

Bill Kristol: We’ve always thought the percentage is 3 percent, 5 percent, something like that. Peeling away 5 percent of Republican voters to stay home, or better, vote against a Trumpy election denier — that seems doable. It seems consistent with the polling and the 2020 results.

Sargent: What do you say to these voters about candidates like Doug Mastriano or Kari Lake?

Kristol: A lot of what we do is simply publicize what they say. Convey the extremism of MAGA Republicans — and therefore the extremism of the Republican Party.

Sargent: The underlying principle here seems to be that Republican voters alienated by the MAGA takeover of the GOP should be willing to ally with Democrats, even if only temporarily.

Kristol: Correct.

Sargent: So let’s talk about the future of Never Trumpism. Let’s say Florida Governor Ron DeSantis becomes the Republican presidential nominee in 2024. Are you guys going to urge the GOP voters you’re targeting to vote instead for, say, Joe Biden?

Advertisement

Kristol: I certainly would. I don’t want to speak for the whole organization. But yes. Trump himself departing the scene by no means guarantees the de-Trumpification of the Republican Party.

If that happens more quickly than you and I think, and it’s Glenn Youngkin, not Ron DeSantis, and if Glenn Youngkin turns out not to be the Glenn Youngkin who pandered to all these people in 2021, and is a semi-responsible Republican, that’s a different story.

(Video) The Jan. 6 insurrection, 1 year later | PBS NewsHour presents

I personally have enough problems with the Republican Party having gone along with Trump — and I suppose I’ve done enough rethinking of some conservative dogmas — that I myself am unlikely to be returning to the Republican fold anytime soon.

The fact is, I have not voted for a Republican since Trump became president.

Sargent: Joshua Tait, a historian of conservatism, has argued that the seeds of today’s GOP abandonment of democracy are embedded in conservatism itself. Going back decades, conservative theorists insisted rule by national majorities should be viewed with suspicion, or even adopted a version of slavery booster John Calhoun’s case for minority rule.

Advertisement

Does this play some role in leading to Trumpism’s wholesale declaration that when majorities oppose his movement, the outcome is inherently illegitimate? Do you see conservatism as in some sense as containing the seeds of this?

Kristol: In some sense, with the big caveat that all political movements have their seamy undersides.

It is fair to say that conservatism had aspects that were distasteful — and even somewhat dangerous. It is probably fair to say that some of us didn’t do enough to fight those aspects. But it’s also fair to say that at the end of the day, it was a very different party when it was nominating George W. Bush or John McCain or Mitt Romney than it is today.

Sargent: That brings me to another question. You could argue that neoconservatism, especially as manifested in the Iraq War and war on terror, helped paved the road to Trumpism. It unleashed a virulent form of Islamophobia while feeding an anti-elite backlash.

Advertisement

Kristol: There’s no question that the failure of Iraq — whatever the causes — laid a little bit of groundwork for Trump’s assault in 2015 and 2016.

But the devastating financial crisis did much more damage. Whatever people’s judgments on Iraq, it’s the financial crisis that really damaged faith in elites.

But if you step back and say more broadly, are there aspects of American conservatism that need to be rethought in light of Trumpism, the answer is clearly yes. It would be foolish to watch Trump take over the Republican Party — to watch so many conservative elites rationalize and acquiesce and enable Trump — and then say, “Conservatism is totally healthy.”

(Video) The Last Brahmin: Henry Cabot Lodge, Jr. and the Making of the Cold War

You can’t say that with a straight face.

Sargent: People often come back to Sarah Palin — obviously you had some role in her rise. It’s fair to ask whether Palin put on the table a bunch of pathologies that lead right down to Trumpism.

Advertisement

Kristol: I regret whatever minor role I had in promoting Palin. I don’t know how much influence she had. It’s hard to believe she had as much effect as the tea party.

Having said that, it was a mistake. I think John McCain thought it was a mistake later in his life.

I don’t want to defend myself too much, but I would say this: I sensed a populism out there dissatisfied with the establishment — including the Republican establishment. I thought someone like Palin could be a way of incorporating a certain amount of populism, frankly in a kind of harmless way.

She was not anti-immigration. She was not anti-trade. She was not anti-globalism. I thought if you could attach a kind of populism to McCain Republicanism, that would be a success. But it turned out not to work.

Sargent: It’s interesting that you bring up the dissatisfaction with Republican elites. One could connect that to what you said earlier about the financial crisis’ role in making the ground fertile for Trumpism. The Republican Party really did embrace a pro-plutocracy politics for a very long time that laid the groundwork for a lot of this.

Advertisement

Kristol: The party was more oligarchic than I realized. One always knew the Republican Party was the party of business and therefore of the wealthy.

Having said that, the degree of plutocracy, oligarchy — whatever the right word is — the degree of that was greater than I realized at the time. I think I underestimated that.

(Video) The Great Reset: Joe Biden and the Rise of Twenty-First-Century Fascism English Full Audiobook

There was also the intellectual exhaustion. I thought that was a problem. People like me were alarmed by this. That was the whole point of the reformicons.

But that turned out to be even truer than I realized at the time — the degree to which people had just not rethought anything since the 1980s or the 1990s.

Sargent: We’re now stuck with a double whammy from the Republican Party. They’re still oligarchic, despite the populist feints of a few senators. And they’re sliding into full authoritarianism. Taking those two things together, it really seems like the Republican Party can’t be redeemed by the standards that you have set for it.

Advertisement

Kristol: I think that’s right. One can imagine an alternate history in which the conservative movement realized it was kind of exhausted; it had a good run. You can imagine a healthy if somewhat turbulent rethinking.

I thought that might happen. Instead, the Republican Party went the other way.

We’ve seen it in history before: Economic elites deciding to pursue their self interest, very narrowly understood, combined with the populist exploitation and intensification of grievances and anxieties, and frankly bigotries and prejudices.

You can’t overestimate how much damage the capitulation of conservative and Republican elites has done. Trump by himself succeeding was bad. The Republican Party going along with Trump — and the conservative establishment legitimating and rationalizing and enabling Trump — created the very dangerous situation we’re now in.

Sargent: It sounds like you don’t think the Republican Party can be saved.

Kristol: At least not in the short term. And if we don’t have two reasonably healthy parties, the unhealthy party has to be defeated.

  • Opinion|How reactionary is MAGA? Try the first century B.C.September 7, 2022
  • Opinion|Evan McMullin is showing how to fight rabid Trump sycophancySeptember 8, 2022
  • Opinion|It’s impossible to trust polls — or ignore them. Here’s how to stay sane.September 7, 2022

(Video) State Senate District 6 Republican & State House District 34 Democratic | INSIGHTS ON PBS HAWAIʻI

FAQs

What does GOP stand for in politics? ›

GOP, short for Grand Old Party, is a nickname for the Republican Party of the United States of America.

What do the Republicans believe in? ›

The positions of the Republican Party have evolved over time. Currently, the party's fiscal conservatism includes support for lower taxes, free market capitalism, deregulation of corporations, and restrictions on labor unions.

Who founded the Republican Party? ›

Republican Party

When did the South turn Republican? ›

Following the passage of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and Voting Rights Act of 1965, Southern states became more reliably Republican in presidential politics, while Northeastern states became more reliably Democratic.

What does gob stand for? ›

Third Definition for GOB
GOB
Definition:To Shout About
Type:Slang Word (Jargon)
Guessability:1: Easy to guess
Typical Users:Adults and Teenagers

What do the Democrats believe in? ›

Democratic platforms seek to promote social programs, labor unions, consumer protection, workplace safety regulation, equal opportunity, disability rights, racial equity, regulations against environmental pollution, and criminal justice reform.

What do conservatives stand for? ›

They advocate low taxes, free markets, deregulation, privatization, and reduced government spending and government debt. Social conservatives see traditional social values, often rooted in familialism and religion, as being threatened by secularism and moral relativism.

What political party is against gun control? ›

The Libertarian Party, whose campaign platforms favor limited government regulation, is outspokenly against gun control.

What do liberals support? ›

Liberals espouse a wide array of views depending on their understanding of these principles, but they generally support private property, market economies, individual rights (including civil rights and human rights), liberal democracy, secularism, rule of law, economic and political freedom, freedom of speech, freedom ...

Which party is bigger Democrats or Republicans? ›

On December 17, 2020, Gallup polling found that 31% of Americans identified as Democrats, 25% identified as Republican, and 41% as Independent.

Was Abraham Lincoln a Democrat or Republican? ›

Lincoln, a moderate Republican, had to navigate a contentious array of factions with friends and opponents from both the Democratic and Republican parties. His allies, the War Democrats and the Radical Republicans, demanded harsh treatment of the Southern Confederates.

Who was the first black Republican? ›

In 1928, Oscar De Priest won the 1st Congressional District of Illinois (the South Side of Chicago) as a Republican, becoming the first black congressman of the modern era.

What is meant by the Solid South? ›

The Solid South or Southern bloc was the electoral voting bloc of the states of the Southern United States for issues that were regarded as particularly important to the interests of Democrats in those states.

What are the three most powerful partisan factions in the state? ›

The Democratic Party and the Republican Party are the most powerful. Yet other parties, such as the Reform, Libertarian, Socialist, Natural Law, Constitution, and Green Parties can promote candidates in a presidential election.

Are Federalists Democrat? ›

the Democratic-Republicans. In one corner were the Federalists. The Federalists, led by Alexander Hamilton, were made up primarily of merchants, bankers, and industrialists alongside many wealthy plantation owners in the North and in the South. Most were well-educated property owners.

What is the full form of God? ›

As per most of the beliefs, the meaning or full form of GOD is Generator, Operator, Destroyer. Hinduism is considered to be the oldest religion. In Hinduism, Lord Brahma is described as the Generator, Lord Vishnu as the Operator, and Lord Shiva as the Destroyer.

What is a fat gob? ›

British, informal. an impolite word for mouth. kæft. Why don't you shut your big fat gob?

What does shut your gob mean? ›

to not say anything: You'd better keep your gob shut about what happened.

What are the 3 values of democracy? ›

Legal equality, political freedom and rule of law are often identified as foundational characteristics for a well-functioning democracy.

What are the 4 political ideologies? ›

Contents
  • 2.1 Conservatism.
  • 2.2 Liberalism.
  • 2.3 Moderates.

What are the 5 political ideologies? ›

Post-classical
  • Democratic confederalism.
  • Libertarian municipalism.
  • Social ecology.

What is the difference between left wing and right wing? ›

Generally, the left-wing is characterized by an emphasis on "ideas such as freedom, equality, fraternity, rights, progress, reform and internationalism" while the right-wing is characterized by an emphasis on "notions such as authority, hierarchy, order, duty, tradition, reaction and nationalism".

What does it mean to be called a liberal? ›

'Liberal' shares a root with 'liberty' and can mean anything from "generous" to "loose" to "broad-minded." Politically, it means "“a person who believes that government should be active in supporting social and political change."

What are the Conservatives beliefs? ›

7 Core Principles of Conservatism
  • Individual Freedom. The birth of our great nation was inspired by the bold declaration that our individual,God-given liberties should be preserved against government intrusion. ...
  • Limited Government. ...
  • The Rule of Law. ...
  • Peace through Strength. ...
  • Fiscal Responsibility. ...
  • Free Markets. ...
  • Human Dignity.

What percentage of U.S. citizens support gun control? ›

In February 2018, 66% of American voters supported stricter gun laws, in a Quinnipiac University Polling Institute poll with a margin of error of +/- 3.4%, the highest level of support measured since 2008. 70% of American adults supported stricter gun laws, according to a CNN poll with a margin of error of +/- 3.7%.

How much money do guns make in America? ›

Not only does the manufacture and sale of firearms and hunting supplies create good jobs in the United States, but the industry also contributes to the economy as a whole. In fact, in 2021 the firearm and ammunition industry was responsible for as much as $70.52 billion in total economic activity in the country.

Why do Americans need guns? ›

Firearms are widely used in the United States for self-defense, hunting, and recreational uses, such as target shooting.

What do most libertarians tend to believe? ›

Libertarians seek to maximize autonomy and political freedom, and minimize the state's encroachment on and violations of individual liberties; emphasizing pluralism, cosmopolitanism, cooperation, civil and political rights, bodily autonomy, free association, free trade, freedom of expression, freedom of choice, freedom ...

What does it mean to be politically socialized? ›

Political socialization is the process by which individuals learn and frequently internalize a political lens framing their perceptions of how power is arranged and how the world around them is (and should be) organized; those perceptions, in turn, shape and define individuals' definitions of who they are and how they ...

What is the synonym of liberalism? ›

synonyms for liberalism

free trade. isolationism. noninterference. nonintervention. controls on a system disinvolvement.

What is the largest political party in the United States? ›

In 2018, the Democratic party was the largest in the United States with roughly 60 million registered members.

What percentage of the voting population is Republican? ›

The percentage of voters registered with the Democratic Party increased from 45.1% to 46.3%. The percentage of voters registered with the Republican Party decreased from 27.1% to 24.0%.

Which is the largest and strongest political party in the world? ›

Parties with over 50 million members
RankNameClaimed number of members (Year)
1Bharatiya Janata Party Indian People's Party180 million (2019)
2Chinese Communist Party96.71 million (2022)

What states made up the Confederate States of America? ›

The Confederacy included the states of Texas, Arkansas, Louisiana, Tennessee, Mississippi, Alabama, Georgia, Florida, South Carolina, North Carolina and Virginia.

What started the Civil War? ›

At 4:30 a.m. on April 12, 1861, Confederate troops fired on Fort Sumter in South Carolina's Charleston Harbor. Less than 34 hours later, Union forces surrendered. Traditionally, this event has been used to mark the beginning of the Civil War.

What was the first state to secede from Union? ›

On December 20, 1860, the state of South Carolina became the first state to secede from the Union as shown on the accompanying map entitled “Map of the United States of America showing the Boundaries of the Union and Confederate Geographical Divisions and Departments as of Dec, 31, 1860” published in the 1891 Atlas to ...

Who was still unable to vote in the United States in 1870? ›

The original U.S. Constitution did not define voting rights for citizens, and until 1870, only white men were allowed to vote. Two constitutional amendments changed that. The Fifteenth Amendment (ratified in 1870) extended voting rights to men of all races.

When did the first Africans arrive in America? ›

In late August, 1619, 20-30 enslaved Africans landed at Point Comfort, today's Fort Monroe in Hampton, Va., aboard the English privateer ship White Lion. In Virginia, these Africans were traded in exchange for supplies.

Why Radical Republicans are radical? ›

The Radicals felt strongly that the Confederates needed to be punished for their pro-slavery views and should only be readmitted to the Union after they had abolished slavery among other conditions. They believed that government intervention in states was necessary to ensure abolition and civil rights for Blacks.

When did the southern states turn Republican? ›

Following the passage of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and Voting Rights Act of 1965, Southern states became more reliably Republican in presidential politics, while Northeastern states became more reliably Democratic.

How many times has Indiana voted for a Democratic since 1940? ›

The current governor of Indiana is Republican Eric Holcomb, and Republicans hold supermajorities in both chambers of the Indiana General Assembly. It has only supported a Democrat for president five times since 1900—in 1912, 1932, 1936, 1964 and 2008.

When did American politics become so polarized? ›

However, since the early 2010s, the Democratic Party has shifted significantly to the left on social, cultural, and religious issues. Since the 1970s, the United States has grown more polarized, with rapid increases in polarization during the 2000s onwards.

What do the Democrats believe in? ›

Democratic platforms seek to promote social programs, labor unions, consumer protection, workplace safety regulation, equal opportunity, disability rights, racial equity, regulations against environmental pollution, and criminal justice reform.

What are Democrat beliefs? ›

The Democratic Party (whose logo is a donkey) generally represents left-leaning, liberal and progressive ideological values, thus advocating for a strong government to regulate business and support for the citizens of the United States. Thus, one of the key values emphasized by Democrats is social responsibility.

What party did the Federalists turn into? ›

Eventually this organization became the modern Democratic Party. The name Republican was taken over in the 1850s by a new party that espoused Federalist economic ideas and that survives to the present day under that name.

Which political party came first? ›

Founded in 1828, the Democratic Party is the oldest of the two largest U.S. political parties. The Republican Party was officially founded in 1854, but the histories of both parties are intrinsically connected.

What's the difference between Federalists and Republicans? ›

These two political parties were divided over the issue of the strength of the government. The Federalists argued for a strong central government, while Democratic-Republicans believed that the state governments should be stronger than the central government.

What is the nickname for the Democratic Party? ›

Members of the party are called "Democrats" or "Dems". The term "Democrat Party" has also been in local use but has usually been used by opponents since 1952 as a disparaging term. The most common mascot symbol for the party has been the donkey, or jackass.

What's the difference between partisan and bipartisan? ›

Bipartisanship in different party systems

Bipartisanship (in the context of a two-party system) is the opposite of partisanship which is characterized by a lack of cooperation between rival political parties.

Which US political party is typically associated with the color red? ›

This makes the United States an exception to the general rule that blue represents conservative parties; the major conservative party in the United States, the Republican Party, uses red.

What does DMC mean? ›

Google the term DMC and you'll find these acronyms on Urban Dictionary: Deep Meaningful Conversation, Designated Moral Compass, Devastating Mic Control, and several more unmentionable meanings.

What do most libertarians tend to believe? ›

Libertarians seek to maximize autonomy and political freedom, and minimize the state's encroachment on and violations of individual liberties; emphasizing pluralism, cosmopolitanism, cooperation, civil and political rights, bodily autonomy, free association, free trade, freedom of expression, freedom of choice, freedom ...

What are the 3 values of democracy? ›

Legal equality, political freedom and rule of law are often identified as foundational characteristics for a well-functioning democracy.

Are federalists Democrat? ›

the Democratic-Republicans. In one corner were the Federalists. The Federalists, led by Alexander Hamilton, were made up primarily of merchants, bankers, and industrialists alongside many wealthy plantation owners in the North and in the South. Most were well-educated property owners.

Can there be democracy without political parties? ›

Nonpartisan democracy (also no-party democracy) is a system of representative government or organization such that universal and periodic elections take place without reference to political parties.

What are the three most powerful partisan factions in the state? ›

The Democratic Party and the Republican Party are the most powerful. Yet other parties, such as the Reform, Libertarian, Socialist, Natural Law, Constitution, and Green Parties can promote candidates in a presidential election.

What is non partisan party? ›

Nonpartisan, on the other hand, is an election when no declaration of political party allegiance, affiliation or affinity is allowed by the jurisdiction holding the election.

Is Texas a red or blue state? ›

A gradual trend towards increasing social liberalism in the Democratic Party, however, has turned the state (apart from Hispanic South Texas, the Trans-Pecos and several large cities) into a Republican stronghold. Since 1980, Texas has voted for the Republican nominee in every presidential election.

Is Florida a swing state? ›

According to a pre-election 2016 analysis, the thirteen most competitive states were Wisconsin, Pennsylvania, New Hampshire, Minnesota, Arizona, Georgia, Virginia, Florida, Michigan, Nevada, Colorado, North Carolina, and Maine.

Is West Virginia a red state? ›

West Virginia is now a heavily Republican state, with John McCain winning the state in 2008, Mitt Romney in 2012 and Donald Trump in 2016 and 2020.

What does WDMC mean in text? ›

WDMC
AcronymDefinition
WDMCWhat Dreams May Come (movie)
WDMCWar Department Map Collection
WDMCWest Dorset Music Centre (UK)
WDMCWolfs Dungeon Metal Club (nightclub; Deitingen, Switzerland)
1 more row

What is DMC in law? ›

DMC means collectively the Deed of Mutual Covenant and Sub-Deed of Mutual Covenant (if any) in the form approved by the Director (including any approved variation or amendment);

Why is it called Run DMC? ›

The following year, in 1983, Russell agreed to help them record a new single and land a record deal, but only after he changed McDaniels' stage name to his favourite car company, Delorean Motor Company 'DMC', and marketed the group as "Run-D.M.C.", a name that the group hated at first.

Videos

1. Michael Cohen & Glenn Kirschner UNLEASH on ‘traitorous, narcissistic sociopath’ Trump | Mea Culpa
(MeidasTouch)
2. Illinois Voices: Fmr Rep John Anthony on Trump, Rebuilding the GOP and Criminal Justice
(IllinoisChannelTV)
3. How Big a Problem Are the Wikileaks Stories for Clinton? (With All Due Respect - 10/17/16)
(Bloomberg Politics)
4. Up for Grabs? Jews and the Republican Party - AJC Advocacy Anywhere
(American Jewish Committee)
5. Joy Reid: This ‘MAGA Attack’ On This 25-Year-Old Woman Feels Mob-Like
(MSNBC)
6. Biden Turns Into HOT MESS When He’s Fact-Checked in Real-Time on Hunter Biden
(BlazeTV)

Top Articles

You might also like

Latest Posts

Article information

Author: Aron Pacocha

Last Updated: 11/16/2022

Views: 6521

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (48 voted)

Reviews: 87% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Aron Pacocha

Birthday: 1999-08-12

Address: 3808 Moen Corner, Gorczanyport, FL 67364-2074

Phone: +393457723392

Job: Retail Consultant

Hobby: Jewelry making, Cooking, Gaming, Reading, Juggling, Cabaret, Origami

Introduction: My name is Aron Pacocha, I am a happy, tasty, innocent, proud, talented, courageous, magnificent person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.